Is it time we raised expectations of politicians on cyber security?

When it comes to the issue of cyber security, recent history doesn’t reflect too kindly on politicians. Last November, the Japanese minister of cyber security made headlines for admitting to never having used a computer, while in 2017, Donald Trump claims to have discussed ‘forming an impenetrable cyber security unit’ with Vladimir Putin of all people. Closer to home, Diane Abbott, Shadow Home Secretary, admitted to falling victim to a phishing campaign in which hackers could’ve gained control of her PC and accessed all its contents.

The truth is that politicians don’t have a reputation for being particularly security-savvy. This is something we have largely come to accept today, but should we? After all, it would be outrageous for a transport minister to say they didn’t understand the highway code, or if the foreign secretary couldn’t locate Canada on the world map.

While we should not expect politicians to be cyber experts, their decisions influence our digital safety, privacy, and online freedoms. As such, we should expect MPs to have at least a core understanding of cyber security issues, just as they should know about any matter that affects their constituencies, be it healthcare, education or law enforcement. As we digitise more of the critical services that underpin our society, such as transport, energy, and possibly even our election process, cyber security will become even more entwined in politics.

To that end, Redscan, a British cyber security company, recently polled the UK’s 650 members of parliament to understand where they believe cyber security should rank among the concerns of businesses.

Chi Onwurah, MP for Newcastle Central, is among the most well-informed voices in Parliament when discussing technology matters, and says that earlier in her career, colleagues were extremely naïve to the scale of the cyber security threat.

ICO FOI reveals data breach detection and reporting woes, pre-GDPR

New FOI request reveals how slow businesses were to detect and report data leaks pre-GDPR

“When I was Head of Telecoms Technology at Ofcom, said Onwurah. “I was asked to look at internet security. When I came back with tales of bot attacks and honey traps, DDoS and white hat wizards, Trojans and worms, phishing and pharming, I was greeted with understandable scepticism. It was as if I was describing a war in a galaxy far, far away. But I knew it was just a matter of time before cybercrime went mainstream. Unfortunately, I was right.”

Fortunately, not all MPs today are as dismissive of the cyber security threat as they may have been in the past. Sir David Amess provided an example from his constituency in Southend West, where he described “cybercrime having a devastating impact on individuals and businesses.” Amess spoke of a not-for-profit organisation being bankrupted as the result of a data breach – an all-too-familiar occurrence in recent years.

MPs themselves are not immune to suffering data breaches. Onwurah explained how her office was a victim of a cyber-attack, but fortunate that it did no real damage. “As an MP’s office we had a big department supporting us and there was no compromise of constituents’ data,” Onwurah remarked. “If we had been a small business, we wouldn’t have had access to that kind of support, and it could have put us out of action for a lot longer.” This is undeniably true, as data breaches have become extinction events for many businesses.

Is this the Cambrian Explosion of AI in the UK?

A major report by Big Innovation Centre and Deep Knowledge Analytics suggests the UK is on its way to third place in the global rankings for the AI industry

Madeleine Moon, MP for Bridgend, was quick to suggest a key reason why data breaches are now such a regular occurrence. “Most staff don’t see cyber security as the reason they come to work, or their responsibility,” she said.

“As citizens we don’t leave our doors and windows open, trusting the police will protect us from burglars. In our online world, everyone needs to understand and follow basic rules to protect our data, our passwords and our networks. We need to learn to close those online doors and windows into our systems.” This is a fitting analogy. Unfortunately, people who set secure, unique passwords and activate additional security measures such as two-factor authentication are in the minority.

Moon’s sentiments were echoed by Meg Hillier, MP for Hackney South and Shoreditch, saying “The UK has a huge challenge to step up to the level of cyber security necessary to be protected against current day threats. There is a severe current and future shortage of essential skills in this area.”

The GDPR and Brexit

James Castro-Edwards, Partner and Head of Data Protection at Wedlake Bell, discusses the three possible outcomes for GDPR post-Brexit, dependent on whether we get a deal or not

This may, in fact, be the crux of the cyber security challenge. Industry experts report a shortfall of almost 3 million cyber security workers globally, as cyber security threats continue to outpace the number of new applicants to the industry. Hillier is right, we must find a way of reversing this trend before it is too late.

Looking forward, Steve McCabe, MP for Birmingham Selly Oak, wanted to raise the issue of policing cybercrime. “I feel very strongly that there should be a requirement for mandatory reporting of cybercrime by banks and other businesses to the police. There is also a need for a cyber health check, perhaps on an annual basis, to ensure that staff and businesses are treating the issue seriously.” Likewise, Peter Dowd, MP for Bootle, said “The crucial issue of policing resources and awareness to tackle cybercrime is one that requires more open debate.” As cybercrime continues to rise in scale and complexity, the issue of how we secure our digital spaces, whilst protecting privacy and online freedoms is not something we have worked out yet. Not even close.

The full MP responses are available to read here. What’s clear, is that the cyber threat to businesses can no longer be dismissed as trivial, as some industry leaders and politicians once did. In the face of a rapidly evolving digital landscape, with threats becoming increasingly advanced, we need our politicians to understand the issues and risks at play. We need them to use their influence to raise awareness amongst business communities and shape cyber security national policy that is fit for the future.

Written by Andy Kays, CTO, Redscan

Editor's Choice

Editor's Choice consists of the best articles written by third parties and selected by our editors. You can contact us at timothy.adler at

Related Topics

UK Government